THE ULTIMATE LIST OF CHEAP OLD HOUSES UNDER $50K…and BEYOND ––>
Alt Sidebar
Search
Brick c.1926 Ohio Colonial Revival Under $150K
$149,500
A landmark century-old residence on the city’s coveted North Side! This magnificent Ohio Colonial Revival offers three full floors of living space with 6 bedrooms and 3.5 baths. Timeless character shines through every corner—from tall, airy ceilings and warm hardwood floors to dual fireplaces and charming original built-ins waiting to frame your life.
Do you want a home with Main Character Energy? With more than 3,000 square feet of finished living space spread across three levels, plus a full basement and detached garage, there is room for everyone and all of their possessions and pursuits. Enter through the impressive entryway into a welcoming foyer. To the left, the spacious living room features a wood-burning fireplace and opens into a wonderful four-season room- a sun-filled space with a gas fireplace and bookshelves just waiting to be filled. A formal dining room with sophisticated wainscotting, large eat-in kitchen, and convenient half bath complete the first floor. Upstairs, the second floor offers four bedrooms, including a primary bedroom with its own full en-suite bathroom, another full bathroom and huge built-ins for all of your linen storage needs. The third floor adds even more versatility with two additional bedroom/flex spaces and another full bath- perfect for guests, home offices, studios and hobbies. The full basement provides space for laundry, workshops and plenty of storage. The backyard houses the two-car brick garage with a new roof and a peaceful outdoor green space. This home showcases craftsmanship, character, and generous proportions that are an increasingly hard to find combination. Turn the page to a home filled with the beauty and good bones you’ve been searching for!
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
Youngstown offers some of the lowest housing costs in the nation, with median home prices sitting well under $100,000. It provides incredible purchasing power for first-time home buyers, real estate investors, and remote workers looking to minimize living expenses.
Mill Creek MetroParks
Covering over 2,600 acres, Mill Creek Park is one of the premier urban park systems in the country. It features scenic hiking trails, lakes, historic bridges, the Fellows Riverside Gardens, a golf course, and extensive green space right within the city.
Youngstown State University (YSU)
YSU brings youth, energy, cultural events, and affordable higher education to the city center. It anchors the downtown core, driving local arts, collegiate athletics, and research partnerships.
Strategic Location Between Major Metros
Positioned directly between Cleveland (~1 hour drive) and Pittsburgh (~1 hour drive), residents enjoy easy weekend access to major international airports, professional sports teams, world-class healthcare systems (Cleveland Clinic, UPMC), and cultural amenities.
Local Culture & Dining
The city takes immense pride in its blue-collar heritage and famous regional cuisine—notably Youngstown-style pizza (Brier Hill pizza), classic Italian bakeries, and traditional Eastern European comfort foods.
Cons of Living in Youngstown, OH
Economic Restructuring & Local Job Market
Following the collapse of the steel industry, Youngstown experienced significant long-term economic contraction and population loss. High-paying corporate and specialized career opportunities within city limits remain limited, forcing many professionals to commute.
Elevated Crime Rates in Select Areas
Like many post-industrial urban centers, Youngstown experiences higher rates of property and violent crime compared to national averages. Crime is concentrated in specific neighborhoods, making neighborhood research and location selection critical for buyers.
Property & Local Tax Burden
Income tax and property tax rates across Mahoning County can feel relatively high compared to property valuations and available public services.
Public School System Challenges
The Youngstown City School District has historically struggled with academic performance metrics and state ratings. Families with children often explore suburban public districts (like Boardman, Canfield, or Poland) or private schooling options.
Cloudy, Cold Midwestern Winters
Northeast Ohio experiences cold, snow-heavy winters with frequent overcast, gloomy skies running from November through April, requiring regular snow removal and seasonal heating costs.
2318 Selma Ave, Youngstown, OH 44504
2318 Selma Ave, Youngstown, OH 44504
