c.1822 Historic New York Church For Sale on 0.72 Acre $120K

OHU50K Notes $120,000

c.1822 Historic New York Church For Sale on 0.72 Acre. What an interesting opportunity to own a historic church turned residence. A short walk to the library and post office.

House View featured at 2098 River St, Lisle, NY, 13797

Realtor Comments

Built in 1822 and converted to a private residence in the late 1970s, this historic property showcases exceptional original craftsmanship. Set directly on the Tioughnioga River, it features 40-ft ceilings, extensive original stained glass, and a dramatic upper-level primary suite with balcony views over the main hall. Constructed with 18″ beams, floor-to-ceiling pillars, and a preserved 900 lb original brass bell, the home retains exceptional historic character. A 1914 stained glass triptych serves as a centerpiece. Recent upgrades include a 2018 Amish-installed metal roof, updated PEX plumbing, modern electric, and efficient ductless Rinnai propane heating plus a refurbished 90,000 BTU coal stove. Enjoy spacious side yards, river access for kayaking toward Whitney Point Reservoir, and proximity to a village park with seasonal pool. Not located in a flood risk zone due to levee protection. Ideal as a primary residence, retreat, or potential Airbnb near Ithaca (27 miles west).

2 bed
1 bath
Build date 1822

Exterior featured at 2098 River St, Lisle, NY, 13797

If interested in a property, pleases contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

2098 River St, Lisle, NY 13797 $120,000

Contact Realtor: Steven Mandeville
Google Map
Niche

History

Pros of Lisle, New York

Rural setting with natural beauty

Lisle is a small town in the Southern Tier region of New York, known for rolling hills, forests, streams, and scenic countryside.
The area appeals to people who enjoy hiking, hunting, fishing, and a quieter lifestyle.

Affordable housing

Home prices are often significantly lower than in many parts of downstate New York.
Property taxes can still be substantial by national standards, but housing costs are generally affordable relative to larger New York markets.

Small-town community

Residents often value the close-knit atmosphere and local community events.
The town’s small population can make it easier to get involved in local organizations and activities.

Access to larger towns and services

Lisle is within commuting distance of Binghamton, which provides shopping, healthcare, restaurants, and employment opportunities.
Nearby Cortland offers additional services and educational resources.

Four-season climate

Many residents enjoy distinct seasons, including colorful autumn foliage and winter recreation opportunities.

Cons of Lisle, New York

Limited local job market

Employment opportunities within Lisle itself are limited.
Many residents commute to Binghamton, Cortland, or other nearby communities for work.

Rural amenities

Shopping, dining, entertainment, and healthcare options are limited in town.
Specialized services often require driving to larger nearby cities.

Harsh winters

Snowfall can be significant, and winter weather may affect commuting and travel.
Road maintenance is generally good, but winter conditions can still be challenging.

Population decline and aging demographics

Like many rural communities in upstate New York, the area has faced population stagnation or decline over time.
This can affect school enrollment, business growth, and local economic activity.

Property taxes

While housing is relatively affordable, New York property taxes can be higher than in many other states, depending on the property and school district.