c.1853 New York Italianate With 6.3 Acres, Widow’s Walk, View Under $75K
OHU50K Notes $74,900

Realtor Comments
Step back in time with this unique 4-bedroom, 3-bath home nestled on 6.3 acres in the Village of Cohocton, with an additional 4 acres available for purchase. Built in 1853, this property is full of charm and character, featuring gorgeous hardwood floors throughout, a spacious attached 2-car garage, and a large detached barn. A stunning cupola crowns the home, adding to its historic appeal. While it does need some updates and currently does not have a running heat source, it is brimming with potential. With its spacious layout, original details, and expansive acreage, this home is ready to be brought back to life and enjoyed for years to come.
- 4 bed
- 1.5+bath
- 3,137 sqft
- 6.3 acre lot
- Build date 1853

10 S Main St, Cohocton, NY 14826 $74,900
- Contact Realtor: Jennelle J. Zonnevylle
- Google Map
- Niche









Pros of Cohocton, NY
-
Low Cost of Living & Affordable Housing
-
Housing costs are well below national average. Cohocton home values are much lower than many parts of New York.
-
Rent is also cheaper than in many NY areas.
-
Overall cost of living is ~21‑22% lower than the U.S. average; ~35‑36% lower than the NY state average.
-
-
High Homeownership Rate
-
A large share of households own their homes. Around 78% homeownership in recent data.
-
Because homes are affordable, more people may afford homes rather than renting.
-
-
Smaller, Quiet / More Rural or “Sparse‑Suburban” Feel
-
Cohocton is small (village population under ~1,000, town larger) and sparsely populated.
-
Less traffic, less congestion, more space, more nature; likely more peace and quiet.
-
-
Decent Median Household Income Growth & Moderate Affluence for the Size
-
Median household income around $64,000+ in recent data
-
Though income is below some metropolitan areas, relative to the cost of living, many households may have reasonable purchasing power.
-
-
Strong Community & Rural Character
-
Many people who live there like the “scene” — nature, streams, rivers, hills. For people who prefer a rural or small‑town pace, it can be nice.
-
Fewer people per household than average, more homeownership which can correlate with stability.
-
-
Housing Market Trends
-
Home listing prices have been trending upward recently (e.g. +20‑25%) in some reports. If you own, this can help with appreciation.
-
Cons / Challenges of Cohocton, NY
-
Limited Job Opportunities / Economic Activity
-
Being a small/rural area means fewer large employers. Many jobs are likely local, small scale, agriculture, or in service sectors. More specialized or high‑paying jobs may be far away.
-
Some residents report needing to travel for shopping, entertainment, or even daily necessities.
-
-
Population Decline or Slow Growth
-
Population has been shrinking slightly; estimates show declines over recent years.
-
Decline in population can reduce local tax base, possibly leading to fewer services or slower investment in infrastructure.
-
-
Education Outcomes Mixed / Lower in Some Cases
-
Cohocton Elementary School, for example, is ranked in the bottom 50% in NY for reading proficiency.
-
Smaller schools may have fewer resources or programs.
-
-
Fewer Amenities & More Reliance on Driving
-
Amenities (retail, restaurants, entertainment, healthcare) are sparse; many things require driving. Public transport is minimal or non‑existent.
-
Services often further away than in more suburban/urban areas.
-
-
Poverty Rate is Moderately High
-
About ~18–19% of residents below the poverty line in recent data.
-
For children under 18, the rate can be higher, which may tie into local educational or social service challenges.
-
-
Limited Diversity
-
Racial/ethnic makeup is heavily skewed: overwhelmingly White, little diversity in residents. Some people may prefer more multicultural settings.
-
-
Housing Market Volatility & Smaller Inventory
-
Though home values are low, in recent reports there’s been upward movement, which can make affordability creep upward.
-
Also, smaller inventory means fewer choices when you’re searching.
-




















You May Also Like
Circa 1897 Virginia Handyman Special With Views $29K
March 27, 2023
Under $75K Thursday – c.1915 Texas Handyman Special Under $70K
September 12, 2024