c.1860 Four Bedroom New York Home For Sale on 5.4 Acres $175K
$175,000
New York hot for sale! This hidden gem is ready for your personal touch to bring out the full beauty and potential it has to offer.
Realtor Comments
Welcome to this amazing opportunity to bring your vision and unique touches to this this 4-bedroom home located in the Whitney Point School District. It is said that this was where Millard Fillmores governess stayed from time to time when in the area. The grounds and gardens await your green thumb find again their beauty and hey, who doesnt need some work after theyve been around well over 100 years. Furnace was last serviced in 2025. There will need to be work completed to bring this home back to all its glory but dont miss your opportunity! Shes worth it!
- 4bed
- 1.5+bath
- Circa 1860
2421 W Main St, Whitney Pt, NY 13862 $175,000
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
Pros
• Affordable Housing & Low Living Costs
-
Housing is more accessible than in many parts of New York—median home value ~$154K, about 55% below the U.S. average
-
Rent is reasonable too — roughly $890/month for a 2‑bedroom, nearly 38% less than the national average
-
Overall cost of living sits around 19–22% below U.S. levels and ~33% lower than typical NY state costs .
• Tight-Knit Small-Town Community
-
Under 1,000 residents fosters a strong sense of belonging—locals often know each other and support one another
-
Active community events like the Broome County Fair, festivals, fairs, and car shows enrich local life
• Access to Nature & Recreation
-
Located by Whitney Point Reservoir and Dorchester Park—offering boating, fishing, swimming, walking trails, and seasonal activities
-
Clean air and plenty of green space, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts
• Good Schools
-
School district earns a B– grade: nice student-teacher ratio (11:1), small class sizes, and graduation rates around 87%
• Convenient Location
-
Easy access to I-81; roughly 20–45 minutes from Binghamton, Cortland, Syracuse, Ithaca, and even Pennsylvania—ideal for day trips or commuting
⚠️ Cons
• Rural Living with Limited Amenities
-
Small-town environment brings fewer dining, shopping, and entertainment options—you’re likely to drive for varied experiences .
-
Public transit is minimal; owning a car is practically a necessity .
• Crime & Safety Are Mixed
-
Overall crime rate is near the national average, but higher than many peer communities—your chance of a crime incident is about 1 in 129 annually
• Economic Challenges & Poverty Levels
-
Poverty rate is around 27.5%—significantly above the national average (12.5%)
-
Median household income is lower than many US averages, though cost of living offsets some of that reality .
• Harsh Winters & Less Seasonal Variety
-
Winters are cold and snowy—outdoor activities slow down, though summer offers vibrant recreation .
-
Weather rating sits at C–; humidity can be an issue in summer months .
• Limited Healthcare & Specialist Access
-
Basic care available locally, but for specialized services (especially pediatric or complex care), a trip to Binghamton is necessary
