c.1870 New York Italianate Fixer Upper $59,900

Realtor Comments

Welcome to the Weeks’s Mansion this home has over 4000 sq ft. Wait until you see the beautiful Architectural details. The weeks home was built around 1870. It has beautiful sights looking down 8th St. You can see the house for about half a mile as you come up the hill. This two and on half story, cross gabled residence with a tower combines the plan of an Italian villa with Eastlake woodwork details. The level of craftsmanship and detail is outstanding. This property includes a frame garage. It does have a shared driveway and comes with the lot behind. A new roof was just put on seller said it cost $42, 000.

• Contact Realtor: Heather Shea-Canaley
  Brokered by: ERA Team VP Real Estate

*

*

Look at that strong staircase! Ugh, I’m so in-love! New York fixer uppers really know how to steal my heart.

*

*

*

Pros — What Many Residents and Data Highlight

Very Affordable Living

• Housing costs in Jamestown are significantly lower than the national and New York state averages, making home buying and renting much more attainable for many people.

• Overall cost of living is notably below the U.S. average.

Community & Culture

• Jamestown has a distinct cultural scene, including attractions like the National Comedy Center and local festivals.

• Smaller community size can make it easier to connect with neighbors and build relationships.

Recreation & Nature Nearby

• The city is close to outdoor attractions: Chautauqua Lake, Lake Erie, parks, trails, and opportunities for boating, fishing, hiking, and winter sports.

• Four distinct seasons — including snowy winters — appeal to people who like seasonal variety.

Convenient Small-City Travel

• Traffic is typically light and many places are easy to reach by car.

• Short commutes are common, though public transit is limited.

Some Positive Community Elements

• There are local groups and events that foster inclusion and community engagement (e.g., local Pride activities).

---

Cons — Challenges and Common Concerns

High Crime and Safety Issues

• Official data and local reports indicate higher crime rates (both violent and property crime) than national averages, contributing to safety concerns.

• Some residents warn about drug activity and safety issues in certain neighborhoods.

Economic and Job Market Challenges

• Median income in Jamestown is below national averages, and poverty and unemployment rates tend to be higher.

• Employment opportunities, especially for career growth or high-paying jobs, are limited compared with larger cities.

Downtown and Housing Issues

• Parts of the city have aging or distressed housing stock, and some neighborhoods show signs of disinvestment.

• While housing is cheap, some residents feel prices don’t always reflect quality.

Harsh Winter Weather

• Lake-effect snow can result in heavy snowfall and long winters, which isn’t ideal for everyone.

Limited Amenities & Nightlife

• Nightlife and entertainment options are relatively limited compared with larger cities, and some residents feel there aren’t many things to do locally.

Population Decline

• Jamestown’s population has been declining, which can impact economic vitality and local services.

*