c.1875 New York Italianate MultiFamily Home For Sale $135K
$135,000
An exceptional chance to revive a historic New York Italianate brimming with charm and potential. This sturdy home, complete with a solid basement, offers a flexible layout but requires significant renovation. Just 5 minutes from NYS Thruway Exit 29, it’s being sold as-is. Ideal for cash buyers or those using a rehab loan.

Realtor Comments
First time on the market in nearly 60 years! A stately brick Italianate with incredible original details, ready for restoration. Once a 2-family, it can be easily be converted back to a single-family with up to 6 bedrooms or returned to multi-family use. Features include a majestic belvedere, stylish curved windows and wood-work, high & tin ceilings, pocket doors, center staircase, curved French doors, unique built-ins, fireplaces, and even bedroom sinks, exampling a bygone era of gracious living. The carriage barn has 3 lifting doors .
- 6bed
- 2bath
- 3,707sqft
- 0.46acre lot
- Circa 1875

25 Willett St, Fort Plain, NY 13339 $135,000
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

Pros of Living in Fort Plain, NY
1. Affordable Cost of Living
Fort Plain boasts a cost of living approximately 20% lower than the national average and 34% lower than the New York state average. Housing is particularly affordable, with median home prices around $137,500, which is 59.3% less expensive than the national average. Renting a two-bedroom unit averages $950 per month, significantly lower than both state and national averages.
2. Low Crime Rates
The village experiences crime rates 46% lower than the national average. Violent crimes are 40% lower, and property crimes are also below national figures, contributing to a sense of safety among residents.
3. Scenic and Historic Charm
Nestled in the Mohawk Valley, Fort Plain offers picturesque views and historic architecture. The area’s natural beauty and small-town atmosphere appeal to those seeking a quieter lifestyle.
4. Community-Oriented Living
With a population of approximately 2,274, Fort Plain fosters a tight-knit community where residents often know each other, enhancing the sense of belonging and neighborliness.
❌ Cons of Living in Fort Plain, NY
1. Limited Economic Opportunities
The local economy offers fewer job opportunities, particularly in specialized fields, which may require residents to commute to nearby towns or cities for employment.
2. Aging Infrastructure
Some residents have noted that certain areas of Fort Plain have aging infrastructure and homes in need of maintenance, which can affect the overall aesthetic and functionality of the community.
3. Limited Amenities
As a small village, Fort Plain has fewer amenities such as shopping centers, entertainment venues, and dining options, necessitating travel to larger towns for a broader selection of services.
4. Educational Challenges
While the public schools in Fort Plain are considered above average, some residents have expressed concerns about the quality of education, indicating room for improvement in the local school system.





















































































c.1907 Affordable Illinois Home $56K
You May Also Like
c.1842 New York Church For Sale Reduced to $49K
March 29, 2025
Circa 1970 Starter Home For Sale in SC $45K
January 25, 2023