c.1890 5 Bedroom 4 bath Beautiful Pennsylvania Home Under $190K
OHU50K Notes $189,900

Realtor Comments
OPEN HOUSE – Sunday, November 30th, 11:30 AM – 1:00 PM. Originally built in 1890, this 2,300+ square-foot residence has stood the test of time and offers the best of both worlds with classic Victorian charm and modern comfort. Nestled on a .31-acre lot in the heart of town, it feels spacious and bright, and the established gardens and mature fruit vines are rare and impressive. The welcoming wraparound porch is your lead-in to original hardwood floors & trim, staircases & banisters, high ceilings, and an expansive floor plan that boasts a full, walk-up attic. Notable improvements throughout the home include 28 replacement windows, a metal roof, a programmable thermostat, and a remodeled kitchen, along with a full bath. This is more than a home – it’s a one-of-a-kind blend of past and present, ready to welcome its next chapter.
- 5 bed
- 4 bath
- 2,330 sqft
- 0.31 acre lot
- Build date 1890









Pros —
• Generally safe & low crime
-
Overall crime rate is significantly lower than the U.S. average.
-
Some assessments rate property-crime as quite low (for example, property crime gets an A+ rating in certain neighborhood-safety analyses).
-
Many residents report the town as “quiet,” “safe,” “dog-friendly,” and good for kids.
• Solid income levels and stable economic / employment indicators (relative to many small towns)
-
Recent data show a relatively high median household income in Pleasant Gap: around $75,625.
-
The per-capita income and general socioeconomic status metrics look favorable compared to many rural/small-town areas.
-
Unemployment appears low and employment conditions relatively stable (per some local-economy summaries).
• Homeownership rate & housing affordability (though changing)
-
A good proportion of homes are owner-occupied rather than rental, which tends to indicate community stability.
-
As of recent years, the median property value remains below many hot real-estate markets in the U.S.
-
Commute times for many residents are modest — average around 20 minutes.
• Small-town / semi-rural vibe — calm, community-oriented, pleasant for families or those wanting a quieter life
-
Pleasant Gap is described as having a “rural feel,” with many residents owning homes, making it a more stable, community-oriented place.
-
For families with children, many point to the local public-school options and general family-friendliness as a benefit.
-
The area tends to be more peaceful compared with big cities — fewer crowds, quieter neighborhoods, and often a sense of “everyone knows each other.”
Cons / Trade-offs —
• Rising housing costs & competitive real estate market (recent trend)
-
The housing market has heated up: recent data show the median sale price of a home in Pleasant Gap was around USD 270,000, up nearly 50% compared to the prior year.
-
Homes seem to sell quickly now (often within a couple weeks), which suggests demand is strong and supply tighter — this can make buying difficult.
-
While previously housing was more affordable, some recent neighborhood-value analyses suggest prices and affordability vary considerably depending on the part of town.
• Limited local amenities & services — reliance on car / commute for convenience
-
Pleasant Gap scores poorly on “amenities” (shopping, nightlife, specialized services) — many residents say amenities aren’t within easy walking distance.
-
For many errands, socializing, or work, residents report needing a car; public transit seems minimal or not ideal for all needs.
-
Some feel the “retail atmosphere” or social convenience is limited, especially for younger people — comfortable but possibly a bit sleepy.
• Population and growth / shift — modest size, possibly limited growth or turnover
-
The population is small (~3,100 or so), which helps the quiet, close-knit feel — but that also means fewer diverse services, events, or cultural variety compared with larger towns or cities.
-
Smaller population may entail fewer job opportunities locally — for specialized careers or diverse industries you might have to commute outside the immediate area.
• Mixed educational / demographic diversity and limited cultural / demographic variety
-
The racial / ethnic diversity is fairly low: a large majority of the community is White (non-Hispanic), with small representation from other groups per recent data.
-
Some education-level statistics: while a portion has college degrees, many have high school or associate-level education — fewer with advanced degrees compared with urban/suburban areas.
-
For those seeking a more diverse or multicultural environment, Pleasant Gap may feel more homogeneous.
Who Might Like — and Who Might Find It Less Ideal
It might suit you if you want:
-
A relatively safe, quiet, small-town / semi-rural environment with lower crime and a sense of community.
-
A stable household or home-ownership situation, modest commute times, and moderate cost of living compared with metro areas.
-
A place suitable for families, retirees, or people wanting calm, stability, and a slower pace.
-
A simpler lifestyle — limited traffic, fewer big-city stresses, and access to natural surroundings (more rural/suburban feel).
It might be less ideal if you’re looking for:
-
Vibrant nightlife, diverse cultural amenities, nightlife or a robust social scene.
-
A highly competitive job market, specialized career opportunities, or industries beyond what a small community offers.
-
A lot of demographic or cultural diversity, or cosmopolitan urban-type variety.
-
Easy walkability / public-transit dependence; without a car, getting around might be inconvenient.




















































337 S Main St, Pleasant Gap, PA 16823 $189,900
- Contact Realtor: Gretchen Knipe
- Google Map
- Niche
You May Also Like
Circa 1950 Georgia Handyman Special Under $47K
November 11, 2022
One Bedroom Wisconsin Tavern For Sale Under $40K
November 8, 2024