c.1890 Former Ohio Church For Sale Under $53K

$52,500

Incredible flexibility in a high-demand footprint! Spanning roughly 0.63 total acres across two contiguous parcels, this property pairs the core church for sale (0.28 acres) with a premier 0.35-acre paved parking facility.

Realtor Comments

Discover the historic charm and possibilities of the former Chatham United Methodist Church in Chatham, just north of Newark, Ohio. Built in 1890, this approximately 1,888-square-foot church retains its beautiful stained glass windows and original pews, preserving its timeless character. The basement offers two restrooms, a small kitchenette area, and several smaller classrooms, providing flexible space for a variety of future uses. Continue its legacy as a place of worship, or bring your vision and explore its potential as a wedding venue, place of business, or distinctive residence. Buyers may also explore removal of the existing structure for redevelopment. The building requires repairs and rehabilitation and is being sold as-is, with no repairs or concessions by the seller. Both parcels are zoned R-2 and are located in Newton Township, Licking County, Ohio. Buyers should verify permitted uses and approval requirements with the township. Zoning information can be found by searching ”Newton Township zoning Licking County.” Whether you envision restoration or a fresh start, this property offers an opportunity to help shape the next chapter of Chatham’s history. Parcels included: 059-295778-00.000 and 059-298488-00.000

1bd
1.5ba
1,888sqft
0.28 acre
Circa 1890

More Ohio Properties

7350 Preston Rd, Newark, OH 43055

If interested in a property, pleases contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

-Contact Realtor: Gregory Taylor

Brokered by GARDEN GATE REALTY, INC.

-Google Maps

-Niche

The Pros

Affordable Cost of Living & Housing: Overall living expenses in Newark are approximately 6% to 11% below the national average. While housing prices have risen in recent years, real estate remains generally more accessible here compared to Columbus suburbs like New Albany, Westerville, or Gahanna.
Proximity to Columbus & Regional Job Growth: Downtown Columbus is an easy 35-to-40-minute drive via SR-16 / SR-161. Additionally, Central Ohio’s booming tech and manufacturing sector (including major investments like Intel’s megasite in nearby Johnstown) is driving economic momentum and bringing job opportunities closer to Newark.
Revitalized Historic Downtown: Newark’s historic square and downtown district have undergone significant revitalization. The area features charming local boutiques, craft breweries, farm-to-table dining, and historic landmarks like the Midland Theatre and the Licking County Courthouse.
Higher Education Presence: Newark is home to a joint campus shared by The Ohio State University at Newarkand Central Ohio Technical College (COTC). This brings student energy, educational opportunities, and additional local economic stability to the area.
Outdoor Recreation & Parks: Residents enjoy excellent access to green spaces, including the T.J. Evans Bike Trail system, Dawes Arboretum (located nearby in Newark/Heath), Rotary Park, and nearby Buckeye Lake for boating and fishing.

The Cons

Varied Neighborhood Quality & Localized Crime: Like many former Rust Belt industrial hubs, Newark’s safety and neighborhood conditions vary noticeably by area. While the northern and western sections are generally quieter and more suburban, property crime and petty crime rates run higher near the city center and select east/south neighborhoods.
Mixed Public School Performance: While local schools offer strong extracurricular programs—such as marching band and music programs—academic performance metrics for the Newark City School District score below state and national averages. Many families choose specific neighboring districts (like Granville) or private schooling options.
Uneven Economic Transition: Although new investment is coming in, parts of Newark are still transitioning from its heavy industrial past. High-paying, non-commute jobs within city limits can be competitive or limited outside of healthcare, public sector roles, and light manufacturing.
Four-Season Midwest Weather: Winters can be cold, grey, and icy, while summers bring heat and humidity. Snow and freezing temperatures require typical winter prep and seasonal upkeep.
Dependence on a Car: Public transit options are limited across Licking County, so having a reliable personal vehicle is essential for grocery shopping, commuting, and entertainment.