c.1890 Four Bedroom Indiana Fixer Upper With Original Elements $125K
OHU50K Notes $125,000
c.1890 Four Bedroom Indiana Fixer Upper With Original Elements. Incredible detail and detail throughout this home. The staircase, fireplaces, light fixtures and stain glass bring you back in time in the best way.
Realtor Comments
Welcome to this 1890 large 2 story home in the heart of Shelbyville! She’s in need of someone to polish, scrub & renew to bring her back to her former glory…this home offers over 2400 SF of living space, with 3-4 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Enter this home through the giant front door to see a breath-taking foyer showcasing a unique wood staircase adorned with a stained-glass window. The living room has a non-functional fireplace, but the mirrored dark wood mantel adds a touch of old-world class. The other large main floor room was used as a bedroom and has a closet, but it was originally most likely a parlor, with another beautiful oak fireplace mantel! The generous sized laundry room is on the main floor with room to add storage cabinets. There is plenty of cabinetry in the kitchen & room for a breakfast table. The dining room has 2 built-in china cabinets, large solid wood doors with transoms, and a gorgeous glass French door that enters into the living room. Upstairs you’ll find a small loft area, 3 more bedrooms, a full bath, and a kitchenette (non-functioning, but with cabinets), which was a sunroom. This home is in need a quite a lot, but the roof is in good condition & the heat & plumbing work. The small back yard is fenced, and there is an enormous amount of parking behind the house. Large home, office…many possibilities! Walk anywhere from this home, highly convenient!
- 4 bed
- 2 bath
- Build date 1890
518 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176 $125,000
- Contact Realtor: Sheri Jones
- Google Map
- Niche
Pros of Living in Shelbyville, IN
Affordable Cost of Living
-
Overall cost of living in Shelbyville is lower than the national average, especially housing costs — often significantly lower compared to many U.S. cities.
-
Lower housing and living costs can make homeownership or comfortable living possible on modest incomes.
Short Commutes & Location
-
Its location about 26 mi southeast of Indianapolis means residents can commute to a bigger job market without the high cost of living in the metro.
-
Commute times within the city are generally short compared to urban traffic.
Community & Small-Town Feel
-
Many locals describe Shelbyville as a friendly, community-oriented place with local parks and downtown areas where people know their neighbors.
-
There are community events, local businesses, and social activities that foster a small-town atmosphere.
Outdoor & Recreation Options
-
Shelbyville offers parks, walking areas, golf, and access to regional outdoor activities which residents enjoy.
Moderate Job Market
-
Job opportunities score reasonably well for a town its size, and unemployment around ~4% is understandable for the region.
Cons of Living in Shelbyville, IN
Mixed Safety & Crime Perceptions
-
Crime statistics are mixed depending on source: some data suggest crime is below the national average, while local rankings and resident reviews show concerns about property crimes.
-
Neighborhood safety can vary, and some residents caution about petty crime in certain areas.
Limited Urban Amenities
-
As a small city, Shelbyville has fewer big-city amenities — like extensive shopping, entertainment, cultural venues, and nightlife — compared with Indianapolis or other larger cities.
-
Many errands and activities require driving rather than walking or public transit.
Transportation & Public Transit
-
Public transportation is minimal, so owning a car is practically essential.
-
Those who don’t drive may find mobility limited.
Schools & Education Factors
-
School performance and education outcomes are average to below average on some ratings, and the city receives mixed reviews for its schooling system.
-
Education levels in the adult population skew more toward high school diplomas than college degrees.
Economic Disparities & Poverty
-
Some sources note higher poverty rates and income below national medians, which can affect economic opportunities and community resources.
Who Might Like Shelbyville
People who want affordable living near a big city (Indianapolis)
Those who enjoy small-town community vibes and shorter commutes
Residents who prefer quieter neighborhoods over major urban centers
Who Might Not
Folks craving lots of entertainment, shopping, and cultural amenities
People who rely on public transit
Those who prioritize top-tier schools or high local income levels
