c.1920 New York Foursquare With Original Woodwork $110K
OHU50K Notes $110,000
c.1920 New York Foursquare With Original Woodwork. The high ceilings, built-ins and woodwork are a sight to see.

Realtor Comments
Big, bold, and full of character! 546 Magee Ave is the kind of home that makes an impression the second you step inside. A four-bedroom single-family home in the Maplewood neighborhood of Rochester! From the inviting enclosed front porch to the expansive foyer with soaring ceilings, this home delivers space in all the right places. Classic architectural details meet thoughtful updates, creating a balance that’s hard to find. The first floor features 9-foot ceilings, hardwood floors, and a formal dining room highlighted by a striking beamed ceiling, a true centerpiece that adds warmth and character. The layout offers flexibility for a variety of living arrangements, with multiple rooms that can be used to suit your needs. Upstairs, you’ll find generously sized bedrooms on every corner of the house, as well as a full bath. Need more space? The finished attic provides additional square footage, perfect for a home office, art studio, or workout room. Recent updates and mechanical improvements help round out the package, including a newer roof, Central Air, and maintenance-free vinyl siding. Outside, the fully fenced yard offers privacy and room to enjoy the outdoors without a lot of upkeep. Located in the Maplewood area, this property is just minutes from the scenic trails and river views of Maplewood Park, as well as convenient access to major roadways, shopping, and local amenities. If you’ve been looking for space, character, and solid updates all in one place, this is a home worth seeing. Delayed negotiations until 04/20/2026 at 12 pm. Please allow 24 hours for a response, as the owner can be difficult to reach, but we will try to get responses to offers back promptly after delayed negotiations. Any Potential buyer must be flexible with closing dates due to a 1031 Exchange.
- 4 bed
- 1 bath
- 1,824 sqft
- 4,779 sqft lot
- Build date 1920

If interested in a property, pleases contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
546 Magee Ave, Rochester, NY 14613 $110,000
- Contact Realtor: Eric McQuistion
- Google Map
- Niche



Pros of Rochester, NY
1. Affordable (especially for New York)
- Cost of living is significantly lower than the state average (~29% lower)
- Housing is much cheaper than NYC or most U.S. cities
You can actually afford a house here on a normal income—rare for New York.
2. Strong healthcare & education economy
- Major employers include:
- University of Rochester
- Rochester Institute of Technology
- Healthcare systems and research centers
Good if you’re in:
- healthcare
- education
- tech / research
3. Solid culture for a mid-sized city
- Known for:
- Music festivals (like Jazz Festival)
- Arts scene and museums
Punches above its weight culturally compared to similar-sized cities.
4. Access to nature & scenery
- Located on Lake Ontario
- Near the Finger Lakes region for hiking, boating, wine country
Big plus if you like outdoors without living in the middle of nowhere.
5. Manageable size & low traffic
- Mid-sized metro (~700k regionally)
- Short commutes and minimal big-city congestion
Easier daily life than most cities.
6. Four distinct seasons (if you like that)
- Beautiful:
- Fall foliage
- Mild summers
- Snowy winters
Some people genuinely love this.
Cons of Rochester, NY
1. Harsh, long winters (biggest downside)
- Heavy lake-effect snow (often 90+ inches/year)
- Long stretches of cold and gray skies
This is a deal-breaker for many people.
2. High property taxes
- Even with cheap homes, taxes can be relatively high
Homeownership isn’t as cheap as it first looks.
3. Crime varies by neighborhood
- Some areas have higher-than-average crime rates
Like many cities:
- suburbs = safer
- some city areas = more issues
4. Limited job market (outside key industries)
- Strong in certain fields, but fewer opportunities overall than major metros Can feel limiting if your career is niche.
5. Car-dependent city
- Public transit is limited (mostly buses)
You’ll likely need a car.
6. Older housing stock
- Many homes are older (early–mid 1900s)
Expect:
- maintenance
- updates
- potential hidden costs
7. Slow growth / Rust Belt feel
- Population decline and uneven development in some areas
Some neighborhoods feel:
- underdeveloped
- economically stagnant
Bottom line
Rochester is a good fit if you want:
- Affordable living (especially for NY)
- A mid-sized city with culture
- Access to nature
- A slower, manageable lifestyle
It’s NOT a good fit if you want:
- Warm weather
- A booming job market in every field
- New housing and rapid growth
- Big-city energy































You May Also Like
c.1850 Michigan Second Empire Fixer Upper Under $170K
April 11, 2024
Circa 1925 Illinois Handyman Special $52K – Lovely Woodwork!
May 23, 2023