Under $75K Thursday- c.1923 Indiana Former Church For Sale on Half Acre With c.1830 Log Cabin Under $75K
$74,900
This former church for sale in Indiana has two bedrooms, one bath. Sometime between 2012 and 2015, the United Methodist shut its doors and was converted to residential use. The building is on a corner lot with a detached two-car garage and a c.1830 log cabin.

Realtor Comments
Now’s your chance to own a piece of Cynthiana history! Large .5 acre corner lot. This converted church has the modern comforts of a single family home while still preserving its unique characteristics. The interior features a versatile floor plan that can be suited to fit your needs. The former sanctuary is huge and spacious, perfect for that large living room furniture. Fireplace in the main bedroom. The basement features over 1800 sq.ft of finish living space and an additional unfinished area for storage. Large kitchen with tons of cabinet space in the lower level. The remainder of the finished basement is wide open, giving you plenty of opportunity to make this your own living space. Possible area for a 3rd bedroom. Outside you’ll find an original cabin built in 1830 and large 2 car detached garage. Make this property your own!
- 2bed
- 1bath
- 4,720sqft
- 0.49acre lot
- Circa 1923

10951 Main St, Cynthiana, IN 47612
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
Contact Realtor: KRISTIE KNAPP KIRSCH


Location of This Former Church For Sale
Pros
- Small-Town Charm: Cynthiana (pop. 548) offers a friendly, tight-knit community with a welcoming atmosphere.
- Affordability: The cost of living is generally lower than the national average, making it an attractive option for families and retirees.
- Natural Beauty: Surrounded by scenic landscapes, parks, and outdoor recreational opportunities, including fishing and hiking.
- Rich History: The town has a rich historical background with several preserved buildings and local museums.
- Community Events: Regular festivals and events foster community spirit and provide entertainment options.
Cons
- Limited Job Opportunities: The local job market can be competitive, with fewer options compared to larger cities.
- Access to Amenities: While there are essential services and shops, residents may need to travel to larger towns for more diverse shopping and dining options.
- Public Transport: Limited public transportation options may make it challenging for those without a vehicle to get around.
- Weather: The climate can include hot summers and cold winters, which may not be appealing to everyone.
- Youth Activities: There may be fewer activities and entertainment options for younger residents compared to larger urban areas.
















You May Also Like
Under $75K Thursday – c.1905 West Virginia Foursquare For Sale Under $70K
August 29, 2024
c.1920 Three bedroom Pennsylvania Starter Home $60K
May 29, 2025