c.1963 Lakefront Florida Fixer Upper For Sale $159,000
OHU50K Notesย ย $159,000

Realtor Comments
Fixer-Upper on Lake Geneva – Keystone Heights, Clay County, FL Opportunity awaits on beautiful Lake Geneva! This 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home sits on a .30-acre lake lot and offers a back porch that could potentially be converted into a 3rd bedroom, ready for you to make it your own. Property is on city water with private septic. Cash offers only. No owner financing or creative financing. No sight-unseen offers. All material facts are unknown. Buyer to conduct their own due diligence. Home requires a full remodel and is being sold as-is. Great opportunity for investors or buyers looking to add value in the Lake Geneva area.
- 2 bed
- 2 bath
- 1,004 sqft
- 0.3 acre lot
- Build date 1963

- Contact Realtor: Eric Parsonsย
- Google Map
- Nicheย




Pros โ What Many Residents Appreciate
SmallโTown Charm & Natural Beauty
-
Keystone Heights is known for its beautiful lakes and outdoor recreation, including Lake Geneva, Lake Brooklyn, and nearby Gold Head Branch State Park โ great for boating, fishing, hiking, swimming, and picnicking.
-
The town has a charming small downtown with local shops, community events like a fall festival, and a relaxed โOld Floridaโ feel.
Affordability Relative to Florida
-
The overall cost of living in Keystone Heights is lower than the Florida state average, though close to the U.S. average. Housing and everyday costs tend to be more manageable compared with many parts of the state.
Livability & FamilyโFriendly Setting
-
Keystone Heights scores above average on general livability metrics โ a mix of affordable living, lower population density, and community stability makes it appealing for families and retirees.
-
Schools in the area are reported to be qualityโrated, adding to its appeal as a place to raise children.
Good Remote Work and Peaceful Lifestyle
-
The town attracts telecommuters and remote workers thanks to a quieter pace of life and, by some reports, reliable internet infrastructure, making it possible to work from home comfortably.
Proximity to Larger Cities
-
Keystone Heights is within reasonable driving distance of Gainesville (about ~35 minutes) and Jacksonville (about ~1 hour), so metropolitan amenities are reachable when desired.
Cons โ Things to Consider Before Moving
Very Small Population & Limited Amenities
-
With a population of under ~1,600 people, Keystone Heights feels very small. That means fewer restaurants, no large shopping centers (no Publix or nearby Walmart), and limited nightlife โ many errands require driving out of town.
-
Walkability is low; most errands require a car, and public transportation is essentially nonexistent.
Long Commutes & Car Dependence
-
Average commute times are higher than national averages because many residents work outside town or travel to larger cities for employment.
-
If youโre commuting daily to Gainesville or Jacksonville, that time adds up.
Mixed Safety Perceptions
-
Different crime data sources paint conflicting pictures. Some indexes show overall community safety higher than many U.S. cities, especially for property and certain types of crime.
-
Other sources and resident reviews express concerns about crime and safety, including isolated violent incidents or drug issues โ local opinions vary widely.
Limited Entertainment & Nightlife
-
Thereโs not much in the way of nightlife or cultural attractions within the town itself โ evenings and weekends often mean driving to Gainesโ ville or Jacksonville for events, larger restaurants, movies, etc.
Small Town Demographics & Feel
-
Some current residents describe the area as less diverse and note that if youโre not already part of the smallโtown social fabric, it can feel isolating or โout of place.โ










You May Also Like
c.1833 Historic Georgia Pioneer House For Sale By Owner on 4 Acres $125K
December 19, 2025
Under $75K Thursday – Circa 1920 Affordable Home in Sheffield, AL Under $70K
September 22, 2022