Creekside c.1860 New York Home With Natural Woodwork and Half Acre Under $180K

$179,900

Step into the perfect blend of timeless character and modern comfort! Nestled on a picturesque half-acre lot backing directly to scenic Cayuga Creek, this 3-bedroom New York home offers a tranquil, nature-filled backdrop. Inside, thoughtful updates seamlessly complement classic period charm, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere with endless potential to make it uniquely yours.

Realtor Comments

Built in 1860, this 1.5-story home has been proudly owned and meticulously cared for by the same family for over 60 years-a true testament to the love and pride of ownership throughout the decades. Inside, you’ll find many of the home’s original details, including gorgeous hardwood floors, rich wood trim, and a classic walk-in pantry that adds both charm and functionality. Two inviting porches provide the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind while taking in the peaceful surroundings. Thoughtful updates, including newer windows, roof, and hot water tank, offer added peace of mind while preserving the home’s historic character. Set on a spacious half-acre lot with a picturesque backyard that backs directly to Cayuga Creek, this property offers a rare combination of history, nature, and convenience. Offers are due Sunday, July 26th at 3pm.

3bd
1ba
1,248sqft
0.5 acre
Circa 1860

More New York Properties

301 Bennett Rd, Buffalo, NY 14227

If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

Contact Realtor: Liana Buscaglia

Brokered by Keller Williams Realty NY

Google Maps

Niche

Pros

Exceptional Housing Affordability: Compared to national averages and downstate New York, Buffalo offers remarkably accessible housing. Buyers can find high-end historic homes, Victorian gingerbreads, and classic craftsman bungalows at a fraction of major metro prices.
Architectural & Cultural Wealth: Buffalo features incredible historic architecture designed by legends like Frank Lloyd Wright, Louis Sullivan, and Frederick Law Olmsted (who designed the city’s historic park system). The Albright-Knox Art Gallery (AKG Art Museum), Kleinhans Music Hall, and the theater district give it cultural weight well above its size.
Revitalized Waterfront & Neighborhoods: Significant investment in Canalside, the Outer Harbor, and neighborhoods like Elmwood Village, North Buffalo (Hertel Ave), and the West Side has brought vibrant dining, local boutiques, craft breweries, and active public spaces.
Passionate Sports & Community Vibe: The city’s nickname is well-earned. There is a deep, welcoming sense of community, famously epitomized by the incredibly dedicated fanbase of the NFL’s Buffalo Bills and NHL’s Buffalo Sabres.
World-Class Food Scene: Beyond its famous wings, Buffalo boasts a thriving culinary landscape featuring regional staples (beef on weck, sponge candy, chicken finger subs) alongside diverse international dining and an impressive craft beer scene.
Short Commutes & Easy Navigation: Traffic is light compared to major metros, earning it the moniker “the 20-minute city”—you can get almost anywhere in the metropolitan area in 20 minutes or less.

Cons

Harsh Winters & Lake-Effect Snow: Buffalo receives heavy lake-effect snow accumulation and experiences long, gray, and frigid winters from November through April. While the city manages snow removal efficiently, the lack of winter sunshine can be tough.
High Tax Burden: Property and local tax rates in Erie County and New York State are notoriously high, which can offset some of the savings gained from low housing prices.
Economic Transition: While healthcare, higher education (University at Buffalo), and tech startups have grown significantly, the local job market is more modest than larger national economic hubs, and blue-collar/manufacturing shifts are still felt.
Pockets of Economic Disparity: Like many post-industrial Rust Belt cities, Buffalo struggles with economic inequality and neighborhood-level disinvestment, making neighborhood research essential when looking at real estate.
Public Transportation Limits: While the NFTA Metro Rail serves a central corridor (Main Street) and bus lines cover the city, having a personal vehicle is practically essential for daily life and suburban commuting.