Save This Old Brick c.1850 Iowa Fixer Upper Time Capsule Under $55K

*

Pros

Historic character & architecture

• The West Hill Historic District was listed on the National Park Service’s National Register of Historic Places in 2008.

• It includes many homes built as early as the 1840s onward, showing styles like Greek Revival, Italianate, Queen Anne, etc.

• According to a visitor guide: “A leisurely walk … showcases Muscatine’s eclectic architecture … you’ll discover many treasures in the over 200 homes built as long ago as 1843…” 
  This kind of character often gives a neighborhood charm, a sense of place and history.

Neighborhood appeal & community feel

• The neighborhood is described in a summary as “residential charm and family-friendly atmosphere” in West Hill.

• Its proximity to downtown Muscatine (given the survey area is just west of the downtown commercial district) means you likely have access to amenities, historic ambiance.

• Potential financial incentives for historic properties

• Because the district is listed on the National Register, owners may qualify for historic tax credits (state + federal) for property rehabilitation. For example: “Properties … listed on the National Register … are eligible for historic tax credits …” in Muscatine.

• That means if you buy a home in West Hill and invest in appropriate restoration, you may recoup some cost via these credits.

Value stability & uniqueness

• Historic districts often have more stable value (less prone to wholesale teardown/redevelopment) because the historic status curbs certain rapid changes.

• They also draw buyers who appreciate architecture, so demand can be good among niche markets.

 Cons

Maintenance & cost of older homes

• Many houses are very old (mid-1800s to mid-1900s) and historic; older construction often means more upkeep (roof, windows, insulation, HVAC) and potentially higher repair costs.

• From a general discussion of historic districts:

  “Old housing that will be much higher maintenance and almost never be as efficient … gas bills were pricey in winter.” 
  While that comment isn’t specific to Muscatine, it reflects common issues in older homes.

Restrictions due to historic designation

• Historic districts come with preservation/regulation implications: design review, limitations on exterior changes, materials, etc. For Iowa, the broader impact is described:

  “Historic district zoning significantly reshapes … additional regulations are imposed … even simple renovations may require additional scrutiny and compliance … cost/increased timeline”

• That means if you live in West Hill and want to do major renovations or changes to the exterior, you might face more hurdles than in a non-historic area.

Infrastructure / older-neighborhood quirks

• The area has had infrastructure upgrades and construction. For instance, a “Sanitary and Storm Sewer Separation Project” for West Hill is referenced.

• That can mean disruption, street closures, or older utilities which may need upgrading.

• Also, older neighborhoods may have narrower roads, less parking, older sidewalks, etc.

Potential for higher insurance or energy costs

• Historic homes might lack modern insulation, may have older windows, less efficient heating/cooling systems.

• Some insurers charge more for older homes, though this is very case-specific.

Limited new construction / modernization flexibility

• Because of historic district status, new construction or major changes may be limited. If you want a brand-new home or very modern open-plan design, you may find fewer options or greater cost in modifying an old structure.

The original owner of the home was Stukley Underwood (1820-1877). Stukley was a grocer and later a carpenter. He lived in the home with his wife Mary Allen Underwood (1823-1889) and children Mary and Lizzie.

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

701 W 3rd St, Muscatine, IA 52761 $59,000 Reduced to $54,900

If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended. 

Contact Realtor: Kari Finley

Google Maps

Niche