Save This Old c.1860 New York Fixer Upper With Original Elements $50K
$50,000
This charming New York fixer upper is packed with value, showcasing stunning curb appeal and excellent overall condition. Its delightful Queen Anne-style details include intricate gingerbread trim, fish scale and hexagonal shingles, and a truly distinctive architectural design.

Realtor Comments
An utterly amazing opportunity, rarely occurring in the West Canada Valley School District, to either A) invest in this always popular and very desirable school district, or work to create your dream home from the walls up. A wonderful large lot with fantastic space for new decks, patios. A beautiful wraparound front porch that simply begs for some rocking chairs during the warmer months and a frosty beverage. And, of course, a wonderful school district well known throughout the area. Inside, there’s so much potential it’s amazing: very spacious and sun-filled rooms with high ceilings and massive windows pouring in the natural light. Beautiful nineteenth-century craftsmanship in the gorgeous mouldings, newel posts, stair rails and more. Best of all – the floor plan is truly superb, with an easy flow that rarely occurs in this age of home – including a first-floor bedroom or den and an utterly massive kitchen. Now, don’t get us wrong – this home needs a complete renovation and the current owner has a scope of work for 200k that will accomplish it. So for around 250k, you’ll have almost 3000 square feet of your-own-style renovated living space. The current owner purchased the property last year to renovate it, but life has taken them in a different direction and they are retiring from the renovation business and moving on to new ventures. Let their loss be your OPPORTUNITY to get into a stellar location, into a home you’ll renovate for 250k. A truly amazing opportunity for you and yours to have instant sweat equity, as comparable homes are selling for vastly more. Roll up your sleeves and bring this village beauty back to life today.
- Studio
- 1bath
- 2,863sqft
- 0.6acre lot
- Circa 1860

93 S Main St, Middleville, NY $50,000
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
Contact Realtor: Nathaniel Crossett

Pros:
- Small-Town Experience: Middleville offers a tight-knit community atmosphere, where residents often know their neighbors and engage in local activities.
- Natural Beauty: Surrounded by scenic landscapes, the area provides ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, including hiking, fishing, and winter sports.
- Affordable Living: The cost of living is generally lower than in urban areas, making housing and daily expenses more manageable for families and individuals.
- Rich History: The town has a unique historical character, with charming architecture and local events that celebrate its heritage.
Cons:
- Limited Amenities: Shopping, dining, and entertainment options can be sparse, requiring travel to nearby towns for more variety.
- Job Market Constraints: Employment opportunities may be limited, with fewer local businesses and industries, which could necessitate commuting for work.
- Weather Challenges: Winters can be harsh, with significant snowfall, which may be a drawback for those unaccustomed to colder climates.
- Limited Public Transportation: Public transit options may be minimal, making a personal vehicle essential for commuting and running errands.






























You May Also Like
Hardwoods, Original Woodwork – c.1901 New York Foursquare Under $40K
April 23, 2026
c.1900 Three Bedroom New York Fixer Upper $32K
July 24, 2025