119 W Front St, New Carlisle, IN, 46552. $74,900
Here is a two for one deal – a home and church for sale in New Carlisle, Indiana. The church, built in 1858, is the oldest church in town and is in the New Carlisle Historic District. The one-and-one-half story former First Methodist Church is a frame Gothic Revival structure. It rests upon a basement that was added later. The basement was constructed of dressed concrete blocks that were cast locally at a nearby gravel pit in the 1930s. In the 1970s, the building had steeple repair from damage incurred after a bad storm, but the bell is intact. Subsequent to its use as the First Methodist Church, the building was the Emmanuel Temple, now closed.
The house that is included is also in the historic district and is one of several homes that were built in the neighborhood with its side facing the street.
Home and church for sale. Great opportunity to own a piece of Historic New Carlisle! This is one of the oldest churches in New Carlisle and is waiting for the right person to bring it back to its original glory. Registered with the New Carlisle Historic Society. Original church bell still in the bell tower. Transform it into a very unique residence, restaurant/gastropub, youth center; The possibilities are endless! This sale includes the home at 121 W Front St. 2 bedroom, 1 bath, 1, 088 sq ft, attached garage.