Before and After of This c.1889 Alabama Gothic Victorian
Check out the Before and After of this c.1889 Alabama Gothic Revival. Beyond unique is how to describe the exterior of this home in Alabama. Love the imbricated shingles, sleeping porch and sunburst vergeboards. The seven-bedroom, four-home sits on a corner lot, and from the moment we see the carved front door, we know we are in for a treat.ย Note the wainscoting, pocket doors, hardwood floors and lovely staircase, and that is just the entrance hall! Then we have stunning fireplace mantels, transoms, loads of clawfoot tubs, eat-in kitchen and more.
We first featured this home back in February 2024. It sold, and the new owner has completely redone the home. The price is now well beyond what we feature at Old Houses Under $50K and Beyond, but the new owner thought it might interest reders to see the AFTER, located at the bottom half of the page.
BEFORE


417 2nd St N, Oneonta, AL 35121
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.ย






*
*Town
This Gothic Victorian for sale is in Oneonta, a small and charming community with a population of around 6,600. The city is known for its friendly and welcoming atmosphere, and it offers a peaceful and relaxed living environment.
It has a rich history, dating back to its establishment in 1889. The city was named after Oneonta, New York, and it was primarily developed as a railroad town. Over the years, Oneonta has managed to preserve its small-town charm while adapting to modern times.
The downtown area of Oneonta features several historic buildings, including the Blount County Courthouse, which is an architectural landmark. The city has a picturesque downtown square that is home to various local businesses, shops, and restaurants. The community takes pride in supporting local businesses and promoting a strong sense of community.
Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy the natural beauty of the surrounding area. The city is located in the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains, offering stunning vistas and opportunities for outdoor activities like hiking, camping, and fishing. The nearby Palisades Park is a popular spot for outdoor recreation and features scenic trails, picnic areas, and waterfalls.








































AFTER

Step into timeless charm with this beautifully renovated Victorian style home in the heart of Oneonta. Perfectly situated just moments from charming shops, dining and the entertainment district, this exceptional property blends historic character with modern comfort. The expansive front porch welcomes you into this thoughtfully renovated home that preserves the home’s original charm. With 6-7 generously sized bedrooms and 3.5 baths, this home offers incredible flexibility. The master bedroom and bath are conveniently located on the main level with 4 bedrooms and 2 baths located on the 2nd level. An additional space on the 2nd level would be perfect for an additional bedroom, office or sitting room. A versatile room and bedroom on the 3rd level provides even more possibilities. Historic charm is evident throughout. This home offers a rare opportunity to own a beautifully restored piece of Oneonta’s history. Schedule your private showing today.
- 7bd
- 3.5ba
- 4,069sqft
- Circa 1889
417 2nd St N, Oneonta, AL 35121
If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.ย
Contact Realtor: Jennifer Alderson
Pros
- Lower cost of living than the national average: Redfin reports Oneontaโs overall cost of living is about 11% lower than the national average.
- Housing prices are often more affordable than big metros: For example, Zillow shows an average home value around $218,739.
- Four-season weather: You get all seasonsโhelpful for people who like distinct spring/summer/fall/winter. (Winters can be chilly; summers can be hot/humid.)
- Community + โnot too bigโ feel: Like many Alabama small cities, itโs typically less hectic than living in a major metro.
Cons
- Fewer local โbig-cityโ options: You may have to drive to Birmingham or nearby areas for certain shopping, restaurants, concerts, and specialized services.
- Weather extremes: Expect hot/humid summers and cooler winters, which can mean higher A/C usage and winter driving considerations.
- Job market may be more limited depending on your field: Some residents commute toward larger employment centers (again, Birmingham is a common destination, depending on where you work).
*
You May Also Like
Circa 1920 North Carolina Fixer Upper on 1 Acre Under $46K
November 12, 2022
c.1919 Illinois Craftsman Bungalow For Sale Under $53K
May 14, 2025





