c.1865 Old Farmhouse Style Home in Pennsylvania Under $100K
OHU50K Notes $99,900
Realtor Comments
A piece of Prosperity, PA history that is waiting to be brought back to life with some tlc. Live in the home while you renovate and bring this home back to a picture of beauty and family. This old farm house still has its original rich wooden stairwell, intact exterior corbels, high ceilings, and crown molding. The home boasts a flat backyard for family fun and cookouts, as well as extra acreage to farm or livestock. Come take a look before it’s gone.
- 3 bed
- 1 bath
- Build date 1865
4574 Prosperity Pike, Prosperity, PA 15329 $99,900
- Contact Realtor: Catharine Shrontz
- Google Map
- Niche
Pros
1. Affordable Housing & Cost of Living
Median home value is around $180K–220K, roughly 30–35% below the U.S. average—and lower than Pennsylvania’s avg too
Rents for a 2‑bedroom place run about $940/month, ~34% cheaper than the U.S. avg
2. Tight‑knit, Friendly Community
With a population under 2,000, it retains a small‑town feel—residents say “everyone knows each other” and it’s a “hidden gem” .
A strong community spirit with events like Prosperity Days and farm tours such as Kesabe Farms
3. Good Local Income & Job Stability
Median household income (~$72K) is 8–10% above state and national averages
County-level crime rates are below the national average
4. Pleasant Rural/Outdoor Setting
Nestled in rolling hills and wooded areas—ideal for walking, gardening, fishing, and enjoying quiet country life .
5. Stable Housing Market
Homes appreciate modestly (~5% yearly)—offering stability compared to volatile metros
Cons
1. Limited Amenities & Entertainment
Small size means fewer shops, restaurants, entertainment venues, and minimal public transit .
Residents note little to do unless you enjoy outdoor or local community events.
2. Weather & Climate Downsides
The area experiences hot, humid summers and stickiness in warmer months Winters can be cold and damp.
3. Low Diversity & Slow Population Growth
Population predominantly White (~98.5%), with very limited racial/ethnic diversity
Some reports mention population decline—housing vacancies are high (~15%) .
4. Job Market Limitations
Employment leans heavily on manufacturing and healthcare, with fewer options in tech or finance .
For diverse career opportunities, commuting to Pittsburgh (~30–40 miles away) may be necessary.
5. Higher Costs Compared to Rural PA
Although cheaper than metro areas, the cost of living is slightly above average for rural PA
