c.1887 New York Victorian Home For Sale With Carriage House $120K

OHU50K Notes $120,000

Historic New York Victorian home for sale. Jaw dropping curb appeal and even better inside!

House View featured at 367 W Church St, Elmira, NY, 14901

Property Details

Nestled on historic West Church Street in Elmira, this stately six-bedroom, three-bath home is a rare architectural gem that blends Queen Anne elegance with Colonial Revival charm. From its ornate facade with decorative shingled gables and patterned woodwork to the gracious period details throughout, the residence exudes a timeless grandeur. Tall chimneys, a steeply pitched roof, and elegant woodwork hint at the craftsmanship of a bygone era, while large windows invite sunlight to dance across spacious rooms. Despite its impressive scale, the homes design feels welcoming and warm, offering both majestic presence and comfortable living a true testament to Victorian-era sophistication. Though no longer used for horses and carriages, the carriage structure remains an enchanting feature, showcasing the same quality craftsmanship and architectural detail found in the main house. Its distinctive board-and-batten siding, gabled roof, and vintage barn doors add immeasurable historic charm to the property. The carriage houses mere presence enriches the estates character, completing a setting that is nothing short of extraordinary. This is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Elmiras rich heritage a home where history, charm, and elegance converge in perfect harmony. The property is being sold as is.

6 bed
3 bath
Build date 1887

If interested in a property, pleases contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

367 W Church St, Elmira, NY 14901 $120,000

Contact Realtor: Mark A. Rose
Google Map
Niche

Porch featured at 367 W Church St, Elmira, NY, 14901

Other Interiors featured at 367 W Church St, Elmira, NY, 14901

History

Steeped in history, this home was once owned by Guy Wesley Shoemaker (1866-1948) per the 1900 US Census. He was a prominent figure in the Standard Oil Company during the 1880s and founder of the Southern Tier Motor Company in 1906. Guy married Leonora Richardson in 1887, and the couple lived in the home with their son Jackson and two servants. Leonora’s father was a bank president and shoe manufacturer who owned the Second Empire two doors down. The Shoemakers were also active in the Frostilla Cosmetics and Hygeia Refrigerator companies.
Refrigerator Company. The Daly family and Ireland’s Own now call this home.”

Few properties can boast such distinguished provenance which marry local heritage of Elmira’s golden age with everyday comfort. At the rear of the estate stands a beautifully preserved carriage house originally a barn designed by the notable architectural firm Pierce & Bickford.

In more recent times, the Daly family and their shop, Ireland’s Own, resided in the home.

Closet featured at 367 W Church St, Elmira, NY, 14901

Pros of Living in Elmira

1. Affordable Cost of Living

Elmira boasts a cost of living approximately 15% below the national average. Housing is notably affordable, with median home values around $88,200 and median rents approximately $871 per month

2. Rich Cultural Heritage

The city is home to the Arnot Art Museum, which houses a diverse collection of 17th–20th-century European and American art . Elmira also hosts the Clemens Center, offering a range of performances from Broadway shows to concerts.

3. Access to Nature

Surrounded by rolling hills and the Chemung River, Elmira provides ample opportunities for outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and exploring nature.

4. Proximity to Larger Cities

Elmira’s location offers easy access to nearby cities like Ithaca, Binghamton, and Williamsport, providing residents with additional cultural, educational, and recreational opportunities.

Cons of Living in Elmira

1. Limited Job Opportunities

The city faces challenges with high unemployment rates and a significant portion of residents earning below $50,000 annually . Many individuals may need to commute to nearby cities for better employment prospects.

2. Educational Challenges

Elmira’s public schools receive below-average ratings, with concerns about reading and math proficiency, as well as limited access to local elementary and high schools.

3. Cold Winters

The region experiences cold winters with heavy snowfall, which may be a consideration for those unaccustomed to such climates.

4. Limited Public Transportation

Public transportation options are limited, making personal vehicles essential for commuting and accessing amenities.

Summary

Elmira offers an affordable and picturesque setting with a rich cultural heritage and access to nature. However, potential residents should consider the limited job opportunities, educational challenges, and cold winters when evaluating if Elmira aligns with their lifestyle preferences.