c.1888 Former New York Schoolhouse For Sale Under $160K
OHU50K Notes $159,900
Here is an old New York schoolhouse for sale that has been converted into a three-bedroom, three-bath residence. The garage has been converted into a studio apartment. Love the hardwood floors, wainscoting and original blackboards.

Realtor Comments
Own a piece of history with this charming 1888 schoolhouse, feat improvements financed by none other than Thomas Edison! Orig 20 pane windows made by the McChesney Family. Orig chalk boards still intact. As solid as the day it was built. Brand new roof. High ceilings. 3 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartments. Front and back unit in the schoolhouse could easily be converted into a spacious single-family home. The 3 car garage has been transformed into a studio apartment but can easily revert to its orig use. 2 parcels, 1 of which inc frontage on Quacken Kill Creek. Rear apart has extra room which could be add bedroom. With a little TLC, this historic gem could shine as a fantastic investment property, art studio or a stunning SF residence. less than a mile school and 15 min from Grafton State Park.
- 3 bed
- 3 bath
- 2,737 sqft
- 0.3 acre lot
- Build date 1888

If interested in a property, pleases contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.
3711 NY Highway 2, Cropseyville, NY 12052 $159,900
- Contact Realtor: Lynda Macdonald – Coldwell Banker Prime Properties
- Google Map
- Niche

















Location of This Former New York Schoolhouse For Sale
Pros
- Rural Charm: Cropseyville (pop. 1,602) offers a peaceful, rural lifestyle with beautiful natural surroundings, ideal for those seeking tranquility.
- Community Feel: A small-town atmosphere fosters close community ties and a friendly environment.
- Outdoor Activities: Access to outdoor recreation, including hiking, fishing, and exploring nearby parks and forests.
- Low Cost of Living: Generally lower housing costs compared to urban areas, making it an affordable place to live.
- Proximity to Albany: Close enough to Albany for commuting or accessing urban amenities while maintaining a rural lifestyle.
Cons
- Limited Amenities: Fewer shopping, dining, and entertainment options compared to larger towns or cities may require travel for these services.
- Job Opportunities: Limited local job market, often necessitating commuting to nearby areas for work.
- Public Transportation: Minimal public transport options, making a personal vehicle necessary for commuting and errands.
- Weather: Cold winters and varying weather conditions may not appeal to everyone.
- Social Activities: Fewer cultural and nightlife options, which may lead some residents to seek entertainment elsewhere.


History
















You May Also Like
c.1833 Historic Mississippi House For Sale Known As Alicia $175K
March 25, 2026
c.1825 New York Greek Revival For Sale on 6.8 Acres Under $140K – Dr. Warren Fay House
November 8, 2025