c.1890 Ohio Foursquare For Sale $75K

$75,000

From the rich hardwood floors flowing through every room to the incredible versatility of its 3-to-5 bedroom design, this Ohio foursquare offers endless possibilities. Complemented by 2 full bathrooms, the interior features a dedicated setup perfect for adding a wood-burning stove—ideal for creating a cozy, rustic centerpiece in the heart of the home.

Realtor Comments

Priced to Sell. New sliding glass door in 2026. Roof less than 5 years. Set of pocket doors between living and family rooms. 3rd floor could easily be finished. A little work could make this house a home.

4bed
2bath
Circa 1890

More Ohio Properties

204 E College St, Scio, OH 43988

If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended.

Contact Realtor: Tanis Thompson

Brokered by Howard Hanna – New Philadelphia

Google Maps

Niche

The Pros

Exceptional Affordability: Real estate in Scio is incredibly budget-friendly. The median home value inside the village sits around $85,000 to $120,000, which is significantly lower than both the Ohio and national averages. For buyers looking to maximize their buying power or purchase an affordable investment property, it offers rare entry-level pricing.
Acreage and Recreational Land: The surrounding rural zip code (43988) features larger parcels, rolling hills, and wooded areas. It is an excellent market for buyers seeking affordable acreage, private hunting land, or properties with significant land utility for small homesteads.
Proximity to Tappan Lake & Outdoor Recreation: One of Scio’s biggest lifestyle perks is its proximity to Tappan Lake (part of the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District), located just minutes away. The lake is a massive regional draw for boating, jet skiing, fishing, and camping. The village is also a trailhead for the Conotton Creek Trail, a scenic 11-mile paved rail-trail perfect for cycling, walking, and wildlife viewing.
Quiet, Safe, and Predictable: Life in Scio moves at a traditional, peaceful pace. The community has a neighborly atmosphere with virtually non-existent crime rates, making it an appealing option for retirees, remote workers seeking complete solitude, or anyone trying to escape urban congestion.

The Cons

Significant Commercial and Retail Gaps: Scio has very few local businesses or amenities. There is no major grocery store, big-box retailer, or medical center within the village limits. For standard grocery shopping, pharmacy needs, or dining variety, residents routinely must drive 15 to 25 minutes to neighboring towns like Carrollton, Cadiz, or New Philadelphia.
Extended Commute Times: Local employment opportunities within Scio are extremely sparse, heavily tied to small service businesses or agriculture. According to census data, the average commute time for residents is nearly 32 minutes, with most workers traveling out of the immediate area or into neighboring counties for stable, higher-paying manufacturing, energy, or healthcare jobs.
Depressed Local Economy: Harrison County as a whole has faced economic shifts over the decades. The village has a relatively low median household income (around $41,600), and you will encounter pockets of aging infrastructure and older housing stock that require significant modern updates and TLC.
Zero Nightlife or Local Entertainment: Beyond local high school events, the trail, and the lake, there is no nightlife, shopping, or modern entertainment to speak of. It is a community that entirely shuts down in the evenings, which can feel isolating for younger buyers or those accustomed to suburban conveniences.
Unforgiving Winter Road Conditions: Located in eastern Ohio’s hilly terrain, winter weather can bring significant snow and ice. While main routes are cleared, navigating the steep, winding, rural backroads around Scio during a heavy winter storm requires a reliable four-wheel-drive vehicle and patience.