If interested in a property, please contact the realtor whose link is provided in the post below, or contact an agent of your own choosing. Independent verification of details and status is recommended. 

Contact Realtor: Marc Reali

Google Maps

Niche

Pros

• Central location: Maplewood is close to downtown Rochester and major employment centers, so commutes to the city core are typically short.
• Walkability & transit access: Parts of Maplewood are walkable to shops, restaurants, and services; bus routes serve the area, making car-free trips feasible for many errands.
• Housing variety: The neighborhood features a mix of housing types—single-family homes, duplexes, and older multi-family buildings—offering options for renters and buyers at different price points.
• Historic character & architecture: Many homes and buildings show early- to mid-20th-century architecture, which appeals to those who like characterful neighborhoods.
• Parks & green spaces: There are nearby parks and tree-lined streets that make the area pleasant for outdoor activities and families.
• Community feel: Maplewood has active neighborhood associations and local events; residents often describe a friendly, close-knit atmosphere.
• Affordability (relative): Compared to some suburbs and pricier neighborhoods, Maplewood can be more affordable—especially for first-time homebuyers or renters looking to stay near the city.
• Local amenities: You’ll find neighborhood grocery options, cafes, small businesses, and services within a short distance.

Cons

• Variable property upkeep: Like many older urban neighborhoods, some blocks have well-maintained homes while others have neglected properties or investment rentals that can reduce curb appeal.
• Crime & safety concerns (patchy): Safety can be uneven block-to-block. Some residents report issues with property crime or occasional violent incidents; it’s important to check current local crime statistics and visit at different times of day.
• Aging housing stock: While the historic homes are attractive, many require updates (HVAC, insulation, wiring, roofing), which can mean higher maintenance costs.
• Parking congestion: On-street parking can be limited in denser sections, especially near multi-family buildings or commercial strips.
• Schools (mixed reviews): Public school performance varies; families should investigate specific schools and programs rather than assuming uniform quality.
• Economic variability: Parts of the neighborhood are undergoing revitalization while others lag economically, which can affect services, storefront occupancy, and long-term stability.
• Noise & traffic in some corridors: Streets near commercial corridors or major roads can experience heavier traffic and noise.
• Limited high-end retail/dining: If you want upscale shopping or a wide variety of dining options, you may need to travel to other parts of Rochester or nearby suburbs.

This was the home of Jacob Magin and his wife Emma Wollensak Magin.  Joseph was a president od Wollensak Optical Company, and Emma was a committee member on the Ladies Club. She also took care of the household and the coupl’es seven children, Frances, Madeline, Elizabeth, Emma, Andrew, Dolores and James.

Democrat and Chronicle