Under $75K Thursday ~ Gorgeous c.1892 Upstate NY Church For Sale ~ Sold

13 Main St, Fultonville, NY 12072       $75,000 Sold for $75,000



This gorgeous church for sale in Fultonville, New York, was constructed in 1892 as the Calvary Baptist Church. In 1936, a deacon of the church invited the Rev. Floyd Lepper, a lay preacher of the Amsterdam Pilgrim Holiness Church, to give a sermon. Soon after, the building was transferred to the ownership of the Pilgrim Holiness church with the dissolution of the Calvary Baptists.

The church building was purchased for $1,700. In 1939, the Pilgrim Holiness Church was organized by Rev. A. H. Wilson and Rev. H. J. Olsen with a membership of 25, and in 1939, the church was dedicated. The congregation paid off the $1,700 debt in 1945, and the members had a ceremonial burning of the mortgage papers.

Over the decades a number of repairs and improvements were made to both the church structure and the parsonage. With a declining membership, however,  the Pilgrim Holiness Church shuttered its doors and has not functioned as a church since 1992.

Not only would the church make a stunning home, but its great acoustics might lend its use as a music venue or recording studio.

To window shop old houses of all price ranges, visit our sister website at oldhousecalling.com or Facebook page Old House Calling.


FABULOUS SOLID MUTLI USE old Church For Sale WITH A LOT OF OPPORTUNITIES! Located in a Commercial Zoned Area this bldg. can be used for Commercial, Residential, or Both & is 1 mile from the Fultonville Thruway Exit 28 for easy highway access.

New Kitchen with Cherry Cabinets, Italian Marble Flooring & Countertops, 2 remodeled Baths with Marble Floors (1/2 Bath on 1st Fl & Full Bath on 2nd Fl), 2 Bonus rooms upstairs & 1 huge walk in closet.

Great Acoustics & Space offered within, 150 Amp Electrical Panel, 2 newer natural gas furnaces, 1 operates Radiant Heat through most of the floors and the other operates Hot Air Heat in the Congregation Area which means Air Conditioning is an easy set up. 4 Parking spaces & Total Taxes $1,959 with NO exemptions. QUALIFIED CASH/CONVENTIONAL LOAN BUYERS TO VIEW ONLY.





13ny1513ny1613ny1713ny1813ny1913ny2013ny2113ny2213ny2513ny2813ny2913ny3013ny3213ny3313ny3513ny40Screen Shot 2020-02-26 at 2.34.49 PM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!